Stapled vs pamphlet-stitched: what is the difference?
Both methods bind folded sheets along the center crease. A stapled zine (saddle stitch) uses metal staples through the fold. A pamphlet-stitched zine uses thread sewn through holes along the same fold. The folded structure is identical, so you can choose either one at the end.
The phrase “pamphlet zine” is also used for a small single-sheet zine folded and cut into eight pages. That fold is covered in how to fold a zine.
What you need
For staples:
- A stapler that reaches the center of your open zine (a long-reach or saddle-stitch stapler). If you do not have one, see how to staple a zine without a long-reach stapler.
- A bone folder or similar tool for the fold
- A ruler and pencil
For thread:
- An awl, pushpin or sturdy needle to make holes
- A needle with an eye big enough for your thread
- Thread, such as waxed thread or embroidery floss
- A scrap of cardboard or a folded towel to punch against
Page count and paper
Folded sheets give four pages each, so the page count is normally a multiple of four. For example, a zine made of three folded sheets has twelve pages. Blank or filler pages are fine.
Heavier cover stock around lighter pages is a common mix. Be careful with thick stacks: it gets harder for staples to pass through and for the zine to close properly. Thinner zines are better suited to this binding. For thicker zines, look at the options in how to bind a zine.
How to staple a zine
- Print and order the pages, and check the sequence on a mock-up.
- Fold each sheet in half, creasing with a bone folder.
- Nest the folded sheets inside one another, with the cover outermost.
- Align the edges on a flat surface.
- Mark the staple positions on the outside of the spine. Two staples evenly spaced is typical for a small zine; three may help on larger sizes.
- Staple from the outside cover through to the inside with the zine open flat, using a long-reach stapler.
- Check that the staple legs are folded flat on the inside. Press them down with a bone folder or the back of a spoon if they are not.
- Crease the spine again, so the zine closes neatly.
Some makers cover the spine with washi tape or paper tape to hide the staples, which is optional.
How to pamphlet-stitch a zine
This is the common three-hole version.
- Fold and nest the sheets as above.
- Open the zine to the center spread and mark three holes along the fold: one in the middle, and two spaced evenly toward the top and bottom, a little in from the ends.
- Punch the holes through all layers with an awl, with the zine resting on a soft surface.
- Cut a length of thread roughly three times the length of the spine, and thread a needle.
- From the inside, push the needle out through the middle hole, leaving a tail of a few centimeters inside.
- Go back in through the top hole, from outside to inside.
- Run the thread inside along the fold, past the middle hole, to the bottom hole, and come out through the bottom hole.
- Go back in through the middle hole, from the outside.
- You now have both thread ends inside at the middle hole, with a long stitch between them. Tie the ends in a square knot around the long stitch, then trim the tails or leave them for decoration.
For a longer spine, five holes follow the same pattern, with additional stitches in each direction. Take your time and keep the thread snug but not so tight it tears the paper.
Page creep and trimming
In a thick folded zine, the inner pages push out further than the outer ones. This is called page creep. It can make the outer edge uneven, and it can reduce the inner margin. Two ways to deal with it:
- Trim the front edge after binding with a paper cutter, if you have a sharp one and room in your margins.
- Keep the page count modest, or leave extra outer margin on the inner pages.
Which should you pick?
- Staples are fastest and neatest for batches of copies.
- Thread looks handmade, does not need a special stapler, and tends to be gentler on thin paper. It takes longer per copy.
For magazine-style zines, see what type of binding is used for magazines.
Troubleshooting
- Staples do not go through. The stack may be too thick. Reduce the sheets or use thread.
- Staples are off-center. Mark positions with a pencil and ruler first, or make a simple jig out of cardboard.
- Sharp staple points. Press the legs flat, and consider tape over the spine. Be careful with your fingers when handling staples.
- Torn paper at the holes (thread). The holes are too large or the thread is pulled too hard.