Layout and Design

Is Affinity Publisher as good as InDesign?

Is Affinity Publisher as good as InDesign? A zine maker's comparison of cost, features, file compatibility and who should choose which program.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Cost and licensing
  3. What both do well for zines
  4. Where InDesign is stronger
  5. Where Affinity is a good fit
  6. File compatibility
  7. Which to choose for a zine
  8. A note on Affinity’s current status

Short answer

For making zines, Affinity Publisher is generally good enough, and many people find it a capable alternative to Adobe InDesign. InDesign is deeper and is the standard in professional publishing, so it can be the better choice if you work with other publishers, need advanced features or must exchange native files. Zines rarely need those extras. If you’re a solo maker producing booklets, the main difference may be price and ecosystem rather than capability.

One caution before you decide: Affinity’s product line has been changing. See has Affinity Publisher been discontinued? for the current situation, and check the official website for the latest versions and pricing.

Cost and licensing

  • InDesign is sold on a subscription basis, either alone or as part of Adobe’s Creative Cloud bundles. You pay as long as you want access.
  • Affinity Publisher has historically been sold as a one-time purchase rather than a subscription, with a free trial available.

Exact prices change, and sales and bundles are common, so check the vendors’ current pages. For a hobbyist making a few zines a year, a one-time purchase (or a free option) has obvious appeal.

What both do well for zines

Both programs offer the essentials of page layout:

  • Multi-page documents with facing pages
  • Master (or parent) pages with automatic page numbers
  • Linked text frames and columns
  • Paragraph and character styles
  • Image placement and cropping
  • Bleed and margin settings
  • Print-ready PDF export

That covers nearly everything needed for a stapled booklet. If you want step-by-step instructions, see our guides to making a zine in InDesign and making a zine in Affinity Publisher.

Where InDesign is stronger

InDesign has a long track record and some advanced features that Affinity has historically been weaker on or lacked. These include:

  • Deep scripting and plug-in support.
  • More advanced options for footnotes and endnotes, and more control for long documents.
  • Exporting to EPUB and tagged accessible PDFs.
  • Integration with other Adobe software, and multi-user workflows with Adobe’s editorial tools.
  • Wide compatibility with professional printers, agencies and publishers, many of whom assume you work in Adobe formats.
  • A very large library of tutorials and templates.

Few zines depend on any of these. They matter more for books, long reports, accessible digital publishing and team workflows.

Where Affinity is a good fit

  • Solo makers and small projects. You can handle layout, simple image editing and vector drawing in a single environment, thanks to its integrated approach to switching between tools (which Affinity calls StudioLink in version 2).
  • Budget-conscious makers who want to avoid a monthly subscription.
  • People who like a modern, responsive interface.

File compatibility

  • InDesign saves in its own native format (INDD) and can also exchange files as IDML.
  • Affinity Publisher can open InDesign’s IDML files and PDFs, though complicated layouts may need cleaning up after import. It can’t save as a native InDesign file.

If a collaborator or print shop requires native InDesign files, Affinity won’t work for that part of the process. For most zines, a print-ready PDF is all the printer needs, and both programs export those.

Which to choose for a zine

Choose InDesign if:

  • You already have an Adobe subscription.
  • You work with teams or publishers who use Adobe files.
  • You need advanced features such as EPUB output or scripting.

Choose Affinity Publisher (or another affordable layout tool) if:

  • You work alone or in a small group.
  • You prefer a one-off cost.
  • A print-ready PDF is the only output you need.

If neither appeals, other tools can work for zines, including Canva, Word and Google Slides. Our overview of zine maker apps and software compares them.

A note on Affinity’s current status

Because Affinity’s software has been changing, check which version you would be buying or installing, and whether it receives updates. Our article on whether Affinity Publisher has been discontinued explains what to look for.

The complete guide to layout and design

Zine Layout and Design: How to Get the Zine Look
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →