This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws differ between countries and change over time. If you have a specific concern, especially about a zine you plan to sell, mail widely or that names real people, talk to a qualified lawyer or a local arts-law organization.
The short answer
Yes, in most places making and sharing a zine is legal, in the same way that writing a pamphlet, newsletter or small book is legal. A zine is just a self-published booklet; no license is usually needed to make one, and zines don’t normally need an ISBN. The legal questions come from what you put in a zine and how you distribute it, not from the format.
The main areas to think about are copyright, defamation, privacy, trademarks and rules about particular kinds of content.
Copyright: your own work
In many countries, you automatically hold the copyright in the original writing, drawings and photographs you create, without registering anything. Many zine makers add a short note such as “© Your Name, year” and a line saying how they’re happy for others to use the zine, for example “copy and share freely” or a Creative Commons license. Both are optional, but they make your intentions clear. Make a Zine! by Joe Biel covers Creative Commons and related questions in more depth.
Copyright: using other people’s material
This is where most zine questions arise. Collage is a classic zine technique, and so are fan zines, reviews and tributes, and they often involve material that someone else owns.
- Images. Photographs and illustrations in magazines, books and online are usually protected. The copyright often belongs to the photographer or artist rather than the magazine. Using a whole image generally needs permission, even if you alter it in a collage.
- Text. Copying a whole page of a magazine or a long passage of a book is a bigger risk than reusing a few words. Short quotations with credit are common in reviews and criticism, but what counts as acceptable varies by country.
- Song lyrics. Lyrics are protected, and quoting more than a line or two can cause trouble.
- Fan art and fan content. Characters from films, comics, books and games are usually owned by someone. Fanzines are widely tolerated when noncommercial, but being tolerated is not the same as having permission. Some rights holders publish guidelines for fan creations. See fanzines.
- Public domain and open licenses. Older works whose copyright has expired, and material released under open licenses such as Creative Commons, are safer sources. Read the license terms, because some require credit or forbid commercial use.
- Your own photos and drawings. The simplest way to avoid issues is to use your own.
A credit line or a disclaimer such as “no copyright infringement intended” doesn’t by itself make an unauthorized use acceptable.
Fair use and fair dealing, briefly
Some countries have doctrines, such as fair use in the United States and fair dealing in the UK and other countries, that allow limited use of copyrighted material without permission, for purposes such as criticism, review, commentary or parody. They are case-by-case and fact-specific. The amount you take, your purpose and whether you affect the market for the original all matter. Because the outcome is hard to predict, it’s wise not to assume a zine is protected by them.
Defamation and privacy
If your zine makes factual claims about a real person or organization, you can face a defamation claim if those claims are false and damaging. Opinion, clearly labeled, and true statements are generally safer, but the rules differ widely. Be careful also with:
- personal details about private individuals, such as addresses, phone numbers or health information
- photographs of people, especially in settings where they’d expect privacy
- stories about family, friends or exes that could identify them
Many memoir and perzine writers change names or details to protect the people they write about. See what is a perzine?
Trademarks and logos
Brand names and logos are protected by trademark law. Mentioning a brand in a review or discussion is normally fine, but using a logo in a way that suggests your zine is official or endorsed can cause problems. Selling merchandise with someone else’s logo is riskier still.
Selling zines
Giving zines away or trading them is the lowest-risk approach. Selling copies raises the stakes if your zine uses others’ work, since commercial use usually weighs against you in a legal dispute. Selling also may involve things like tax reporting or local business or market-vendor rules, depending on where you live and how much you sell. Check your local requirements if you sell regularly.
Adult, political and sensitive content
Rules about sexual content, hate speech, incitement and political publishing vary a lot by country, and some regions restrict what can be sent by post or sold to minors. If your zine deals with sensitive material, check the local rules and your distribution channel’s policies, including those of online shops, fests and libraries. Activist makers in particular should think about safety as well as legality. See zines and activism.
Practical checklist
- Make your own images and text wherever you can.
- Credit sources and quote only what you need.
- For collage, use your own materials, public domain or openly licensed items, or ask permission.
- Don’t present unproven accusations as facts.
- Don’t publish private details about people without their consent.
- Label your zine with who made it and how it can be shared.
- If you’re unsure, ask a lawyer, an arts-law group or an experienced zine maker, and consider leaving the item out.
Once you’re comfortable, how to make a zine takes you through the practical steps.